Photo by Science to Business Marketing Research Centre, FH Münster.
In this episode, Professor Thomas Baaken, founder and former Senior Managing Director of the Science to Business Marketing Research Centre shares his journey of bridging science and business over 30 years at FH Münster. He discusses the challenges of fostering university-industry collaborations, including overcoming bureaucracy, shifting academic mindsets, and scaling impact.
With a focus on empathy, trust, and tailored approaches, he highlights successful strategies like workshops and student-led projects. Looking ahead, Thomas emphasises the importance of prioritising drivers over barriers to foster meaningful collaborations that benefit universities, industries, and students alike.
In this blog post, we summarise part of the conversation with Thomas, but you can listen to the full interview on our podcast:
Transcript
Maynara Furquim:
Could you share a little bit about your journey bridging science and businesses and what initially inspired you to focus on the intersection of these fields?
Thomas Baaken:
It was kind of an external initiative because I was doing teaching and research as an average professor many years ago, teaching students how all our colleagues are doing it. Suddenly, I was approached by a newly appointed rector, and he asked me, “Could you imagine, Thomas, to be our vice rector, pro-rector, vice president on research and technology transfer?” And my answer was, “Wow, why me? I have no records of exceptional research or teaching. So why are you approaching me?” And he said, “Well, you are teaching marketing in B2B business, business-to-business marketing strategies. And if our university wants to be more successful in technology transfer, and we want to offer our knowledge and outcomes and research and patterns to companies outside there, and we are asking for something back like resources or money or whatever, it’s a market. And if it is a market, I think you are the best to organise and manage the field”. And I took a few days to reflect, but then I was convinced about the question, and I stepped in the position. And I did it for five years. It was really a challenge because our colleagues, as all the professors in all universities, are convinced or enthusiastic about what they are doing. I observed, for the first half of the year, the processes, and we analysed them, and we reflected on the processes and the strategies. I learned a lot about what we, as a university, are doing wrong. And we turned the entire university upside down. We set up seminars and workshops for professors on how to approach external organisations like companies, how to operate with them, how to listen to what they really need, and how to understand their pains and needs. And then start talking, not about what the professors have done, but about what could contribute to the company’s problems or what could solve the company’s challenges. And that is where it all started.
“But that wasn’t an easy journey because you never will catch or convince all professors, researchers and teachers to do it. But if you get like 20% or 40% of them to change their attitude and their operation and acting, then it’s really a good start. Then, you have a lot of role models all of a sudden, and younger professors are striving or trying to go along with it and so on.”
It was such a big success that the Ministry of Higher Education and Technology of our North Rhine-Westphalian land became aware of it and was asking, “Wow, what are you doing here? Could you please write it up or organise some workshops not only for your own university but also for other universities in our country to make them learn how it works?” And well, I started to think, “It could be a good idea”. I was asking for a little money to start this process, the activity on the topic to get it more organised and more like scheduled or whatever. That was how it started.
Maynara Furquim:
What a journey. I believe you could elucidate a bit on the path for us because you have done it since the beginning for the FH Münster. What are some of the challenges that you have encountered while fostering this industry engagement and putting together all these projects, and how did all these challenges actually impact the success of the results of the projects?
Thomas Baaken:
This is a good question because there have been more challenges, obstacles and thresholds than you would believe, far more than drivers for the colleagues and for the professors. I only touch on two areas of challenges. One is an organisational challenge. There is a huge amount of red tape and administration and bureaucracy in a university, which is really a problem to get it done. As I was part of the presidency of the board, I had some influence on removing a lot of red tape.
“I think I spent more than two-thirds of my time during my whole career in this area, as a vice president or as a managing director of the Science-to-Business Research Centre, to understand all the bureaucracy and the hurdles, to find ways around it or overcome it or dig tunnels under it. You need to kind of get around it.”
And if you stop or if you ask the administration, “Can I do this? I would like to do that”, they always say no. They are no-sayers. And this is a challenge. And many colleagues who really are not willing to do it or not prepared to do it, from the first step, say, “OK, if there is no, I don’t do it”. It was really easy for them not to do it.
However, there were always ways to solve it. If you talk to other people and legal people outside the universities or ministry, you will find some ideas and bits and pieces of knowledge on how you could get around the bureaucracy. That is not easy, and it is not fun, but you need to do it. Otherwise, you are chained at your office.
“And I started to find a way to not ask because it is easier to get forgiveness than permission. We started not to ask anymore but just did it.”
And if somebody was kind of approaching us, “You cannot do that”, we apologise, “Oh, we didn’t know it”. But it is a big success, and so, we got forgiveness and ways around for the future.
Another area of challenge is the mindset of the professors and teachers. There is not much empathy in those people. They have left the industry for certain reasons. And now we are trying to convince them to work with the industry again. And well, some did, others said, “No, I just left them because of some reasons, and I’m not willing to go back kind of in this area, so leave me alone”. Also, many professors, researchers and teachers are much more convinced about what they are doing rather than listening to other people. So, empathy is one important factor in getting a university-business cooperation done.
Maynara Furquim:
And were there any challenges from the industry side?
Thomas Baaken:
Not really, no. All the industries we have approached with our marketing strategy, inviting them on a one-to-one level or small groups or organising workshops. They all have been very open-minded, and they are always looking for opportunities and chances to improve or to get new knowledge or new technologies or innovations. However, we have not launched public invitations, but we have organised approaches. We analysed the target companies we wanted to work with. We looked at what they are doing and what are their strategies and structures.
“We learned about the company before we approached it. So, it is not just, “Hey, are you willing to talk to us?”. But, “I know what you are doing, I know what general challenges you are facing, and maybe we could have some solutions for you, and it could make sense to talk”. So, we have a more concrete rather than general approach.”
We also invited small groups of companies and professors from the university, like 10 companies and 15 professors, and we locked into a room, and everybody had to say what they were doing. Then, naturally, we had pairs of people, and they had to go for one hour into a room. And after one hour, we opened the doors again. And it was really interesting how many ideas came up for this type of workshop. And then, we had a list of priorities. And because I was part of the board and also from the companies on the board level, there was acceptance or approval. Both sides, from the top down, asked after a while, “What happened? Do we have projects? What happened to the project? Do they have progress?”. So, there was a managerial strategy from both sides, following down the projects we had initially created in these types of workshops. And that was really a breakthrough in the field.
We also had tools. The professors had a small questionnaire. Once they approached companies, they had to ask before they started talking about themselves; first, listen. And take on board the wording and the vocabulary and expressions from this industry sector and from this company to rebuild it into their answers and so on. It was a way how to do it.
“However, it is a people’s business. It is not possible to have an organisation working together with another organisation, but a professor with somebody from a company. You need to have single persons or groups of people working together. Trust is an important element. Communication is an important element in getting things really successfully done.”
Maynara Furquim:
We have heard the same in that sense. It is a people business. It is one-to-one. It is a relationship. Everything starts like that.
I’m curious to hear how it has evolved. You already explained a bit about how it started, but over the years, has the implementation become somehow easier with these workshops, for example, and how do you see this integration of industry partnerships impacting the students’ careers and their learnings and being ready to go out there and be the workers of the future?
Thomas Baaken:
The challenge was to scale it. You could easily get some projects initiated in the university on a one-to-one level, but if you want to scale it, you would need to have different strategies. What we have done in our university, and that could be a role model, is this triangle of university-business cooperation. Triangle means we have three organisations or areas in the university. We have the president and the board, and there needs to be at least one, better, more people who are really convinced that it is an important area. Then, we have the technology transfer office as a private company. Its CEO is also the vice president of the university, so there is a lot of connection and direct impact, and vice-versa, in both organisations. And there’s a third organisation, which is us, as a research organisation on the topic, collecting all these best practices and role models and strategies, and to do research on the field, how to improve it, how to make it better, what are the challenges of the future. We are also linked to the board and the technology transfer company and very closely working together with both. So, this triangle makes it easier for this university, easier to be successful in the field of university-business cooperation.
You mentioned the students. We have always tried to incorporate students into every type of project. And that is one of the fields in which we are doing cooperation with companies; we organise so-called semester projects. We are picking up problems from companies. Those problems are solved by a group of students in a teaching format. There is one professor or a teacher who is responsible for the project. And we have 12, 15 students working on it. Then, after the semester ends, the group presents their results to the board of the company. And, from all of the projects, I haven’t heard of any of the projects which have not really worked. The companies are really happy and get more than they expected. They are now asking several students if they could continue the work on the project in the company as an intern or first job or get their bachelor’s master thesis in the area. There is also a connection of the company to the students for the future.
“And if you ask the students once they have finished their studies what was the most interesting or thrilling teaching area of your programme, they always point out this type of project because it’s a real-world project with real companies, with real problems.”
They also get a certificate from the companies on company letterhead, where the company certifies the success of the project to every single student. You can imagine if they are applying for a job after their studies and they have two or three of these certificates from the companies, they have a lot of advantage against other applicants from other universities. They have a lot more experience in the real world. We, as teachers, have interesting projects. We also learn a lot from this type of project to incorporate the solutions in our future teaching, and we have thrilling and interesting teaching. And the company get really great solutions and also potential employees.
“It is a win-win-win situation. And you can really use it as a future strategic teaching area if you have the organisation convinced to do it.”
In our university, it depends on single professors if they want it or not want it. There are only a few possibilities for the board or for the dean to lead people and get professors and teaching staff to follow this strategy.
Maynara Furquim:
That’s so interesting to hear how big it can become if you foster it and really go for it. You already started mentioning that this is a strategy for future teaching and everything, but do you see any other trends or something else shaping this collaboration between industry and universities? And if there is something that is coming now, what could the universities do to adapt to these changes and then keep impacting both industry and the students?
Thomas Baaken:
I think there is a lot of knowledge created on this topic and the way how it could be solved.
“But what I learned from other universities or new colleagues is that they all started it from scratch. They are not looking at what has been done. Where are the best solutions? What can I learn from these best practices or best solutions? They all start developing it on their own again. And that is really sad because they are making the same mistakes, hitting the same problems, rather than looking at how they have been overcome in the past.”
There is a lot of knowledge available, really a lot of solutions available, not only in literature, but in conferences, in conference papers, in white papers, but people are not willing or not prepared to onboard this knowledge. They all start with their own experience again, which is really sad. It shouldn’t be like that.
I am still reading a lot in the field, and most of the research and publications address thresholds, problems, obstacles, barriers, and hurdles. If you look for it, you will find hundreds and hundreds of papers in the field.
“But, Maynara, barriers are not the field to look at. It is the drivers to look at. It is far more important to have the right drivers and motivation to do it rather than looking at the barriers because if you take the barriers away, nothing will happen. But if you have strong drivers and motivation, then all barriers, hurdles and problems are easy to overcome.”
If you google “Drivers in Technology Transfer or University-Business Cooperation”, you will find two or three publications. There is a big imbalance in barriers – all people think that is important – and drivers – nobody thinks it is important. But it is just the other way around. Drivers are far more important. You have to do more research on drivers and motivation rather than the negative side, the barriers.
Maynara Furquim:
Definitely. In the end, the barriers are way smaller, or you find a way to go around. You just do it, and then you apologise if something happens. I really like that approach. If you just focus on the negative side, of course, nothing is going to happen, and that is not the purpose. It is about motivation and being there and making a difference for the students and for the industry that you are inviting to cooperate.
Before we close up, I want to give you the space for any other advice you want to give educators, institutions, companies; or any other lessons that you have learned through all these years and as an advocate for the field.
Thomas Baaken:
If I tackle drivers, we still have that problem in the scientific system in which professors, teachers, and researchers are assessed along with their records of publications in high-impact journals. That is a little bit contradictive to what we are talking about, university-business cooperation. Even worse, university-business cooperation and technology transfer are not even recognised or valued in universities, and the careers of researchers do not depend on that. We should work very hard on changing that, at least a little bit. I am not talking about do not publish anymore in high-impact journals. But why not have a PhD student who has to publish four or five papers, one of them be defined as a university-business paper, a project done with companies, to give it more recognition, to give it more value? We have to change the system at least a little bit in this direction.
“So, there is still a lot to do, but there are also ways and strategies for countries, politics, university boards, deans, and whoever is in this type of position responsible for managing universities, and they have it in their hands to change it: address them as target persons to get more aware of their power in that field.”
Interested in more insights like this?
Check out the Science-to-Business Marketing Research Centre website (https://en.fh-muenster.de/science-marketing/index.php). Don’t miss our last episodes in the next weeks! Follow us on your preferred podcast platform.










